Bonds vs. Stocks: Key Differences

Bonds and stocks are often mentioned in the same breath, but they’re very different beasts. Investors must understand the differences between them to maximize the benefits of each within their portfolio.

Let’s delve into the critical distinctions between bonds vs. stocks, shedding light on details every investor should know. 

What are bonds?

A bond is a financial instrument that forms the bedrock of debt markets. When you invest in a bond, you're extending a loan to a corporation or government. In return, you receive interest payments, frequently referred to as “coupon payments,” plus the promise your initial investment (aka the “principal”) will be returned to you in full when the bond’s maturity date arrives.

A corporation or government issues bonds when it wants to raise capital. The issuance process involves setting a fixed interest rate, which determines the periodic payments to bondholders. Unlike stocks, bonds are debt securities, emphasizing the creditor-debtor relationship between the investor and the issuer.

Investors are drawn to bonds for several reasons, including the relative stability of bonds compared to the potentially more volatile stock market. Bonds provide a reliable source of income through regular interest payments, appealing to fixed-income investors and those seeking high-yield assets.

What are stocks?

Stocks, sometimes referred to as “equities,” represent ownership in a company. When you hold shares of a company's stock, you are essentially a part-owner of that business.

This ownership stake entitles you to a slice of the company's profits and assets, as well as a say in its decision-making processes through voting rights at shareholder meetings—although not all shares carry voting rights.

Stocks are bought and sold on stock exchanges, such as the NASDAQ or NYSE, where investors trade these ownership certificates. One of their primary attractions is their potential for capital appreciation. As companies grow and thrive, the value of their stock rises, allowing investors to profit by selling their shares at a higher price than they paid (hence the old investing adage: “buy low, sell high”).

Some stocks offer another source of income through dividends—periodic payments to shareholders from a company’s earnings. Some stocks also pay dividends—periodic payments to shareholders from a company's earnings—which offer another source of income. Dividends are typically paid quarterly, semiannually, or annually.

The stock market is well known for its volatility. Share prices can fluctuate significantly in the short term. Stock investments are exposed to market fluctuations, economic events, and business performance, with the potential for both gains and losses. Despite the risks, many investors look to stocks for long-term growth and wealth building.

Of course, volatility doesn’t necessarily equate to risk. Investments can be both stable and risky, especially in inflationary times.

(Ready to claim your slice of the investing pie? Sign up for Composer today.)

6 differences between bonds and stocks

The following are crucial differences between stocks and bonds:

1. Ownership

Bonds: Bond investors essentially lend money to the issuer. In return, they become creditors and have a legal claim on the principal amount and interest payments.

Stocks: Stocks equal ownership. Shareholders have an equity stake in the business and may benefit from its profits, but they are also exposed to losses if the company performs poorly.

2. Risk

Bonds: Bonds are generally considered less risky than stocks. They come with fixed interest payments, providing a predictable income stream. However, they still carry risks, such as inflation eroding the real value of interest payments and of the bonds themselves.

Stocks: Stocks are generally considered riskier due to price volatility. Prices can fluctuate in the short term based on sentiment, economic conditions, or company performance. Although stocks offer the potential for higher returns, they carry a higher chance of capital loss.

3. Returns

Bonds: Investors receive interest payments, known as coupon payments, at a fixed rate. Additionally, bondholders receive the face value of the bond once it reaches maturity.

Stocks: Returns are primarily driven by changes in the stock price. Investors can profit from capital appreciation. Some stocks also provide dividends as an additional source of income.

4. Liquidity

Bonds: Liquidity varies depending on the type of bond and market conditions. Government and corporate bonds are generally more liquid than municipal bonds or corporate bonds with lower credit ratings. In some cases, bonds may be less liquid than stocks.

Stocks: Stocks tend to be more liquid than bonds. They’re actively traded on exchanges, allowing investors to buy and sell shares quickly. 

5. Influence on company

Bonds: Bondholders do not have voting rights or significant influence on company decisions. They’re primarily concerned with receiving their interest payments and the return of the principal.

Stocks: Some shareholders have voting rights and can influence company decisions by participating in shareholder meetings. Voting power is usually proportionate to the number of shares owned. 

6. Tax treatment

Bonds: Income from bonds is taxed differently than gains from stocks. Bond interest payments are typically taxed at the investor's ordinary income tax rate. This may result in a higher tax liability for bond interest than qualified stock dividends and long-term capital gains.

Stocks: Stock gains can be taxed at different rates, depending on the holding period and type of stock income. Qualified dividends and long-term capital gains generally receive preferential tax treatment, meaning lower tax rates.

Investing in bonds: Pros and cons

Are bonds safer than stocks? Let’s explore:

Advantages

• Steady income: Bonds offer regular interest payments, providing a predictable income stream—ideal for income-oriented investors.

• Lower risk: Bond prices, particularly government bonds, are generally less volatile than stocks and are considered lower-risk investments.

• Preservation of capital: Bondholders receive the face value of the bond at maturity, offering capital preservation.

Disadvantages

• Lower potential returns: Bonds typically offer lower long-term returns compared to stocks. Returns may not keep pace with inflation.

• Limited capital appreciation: Bonds do not provide the same potential for capital appreciation as stocks.

Investing in stocks: Pros and cons

Stocks may be the more appealing investment, depending on your risk tolerance. Here’s why:

Advantages

• Higher potential returns: Stocks have historically offered the potential for higher long-term returns, making them suitable for investors seeking capital appreciation.

• Ownership and voting rights: Stockholders have an ownership stake in a company, giving them voting rights and the opportunity to influence decisions.

• Dividend income: Some stocks pay dividends, giving investors regular income in addition to potential capital gains.

Disadvantages

• Higher volatility: Stocks can experience significant price fluctuations, leading to higher short-term volatility and potential capital losses.

Ultimately, the choice between stocks and bonds depends on your financial objectives and risk tolerance. 

Embark on your investing journey with Composer

Composer is your gateway to a world of ample possibilities in stocks, bonds, and investing. Our user-friendly, no-code solution offers the flexibility to create backtested strategies using a combination of bond ETFs and stock ETFs. Tailor your portfolio to your financial goals and risk tolerance.

With our algorithmic, ChatGPT-4-assisted platform, you can effortlessly explore the nuances of these asset classes. Harness powerful investing tools while automation keeps your portfolio in check. Start your 14-day free trial today.